1996 Mr America - AAU
| Overall Winner Doug Rieser | |
| Overall Winner Jaime Rodriguez | |
HeavyWeight | |
| 1 | Doug Rieser |
| 2 | Mike Giletto |
| 3 | Russell Parker |
Light-HeavyWeight | |
| 1 | Jaime Rodriguez |
| 2 | Jimmy David |
| 3 | James Eason |
| 4 | Gary Jackson |
| 5 | Charles Moss |
| 6 | Redgie Smallwood |
| 7 | Robert Buonincontro |
| 8 | John Lancaster |
| DQ | Dean Miller (had been 1st) |
MiddleWeight | |
| 4 | John Puskarich |
| 5 | Gary Bobolsky |
| 6 | Mike Brooke |
| 7 | Will McOrmond |
| 8 | David McBride Jr |
| 9 | Baraka Nur |
| 10 | Craig Dunbar |
| DQ | Rommy Abdallah (had been 2nd) |
| DQ | Charles Durr (had been overall) |
| DQ | Zuhir Gazawneh (had been 3rd) |
LightWeight | |
| 1 | John Gaines |
| 2 | Karl Herkert |