2009 Musclemania New York
Bodybuilding | |
| 1 | Dominique Rougier |
| 2 | Ana Bartlett |
| 3 | Dawn Gilday |
| 4 | Claudine Prowse |
Figure Tall | |
| 1 | Jamie Corso |
| 2 | Anne Maas |
| 3 | Heidi Jones |
| 4 | Jenica Allen |
| 5 | Tiffany DeMartino |
Figure Short | |
| 1 | Joanne Amato |
| 2 | Kathryn Szep |
| 3 | Lisa Bretz |
| 4 | Serena Marion |