1996 Mr USA - AAU
| Overall Winner Robert Lee Brown | |
Tall | |
| 1 | Jeramy O'Connell |
| 2 | Michael Stuermer |
| 3 | Gene Cicarelli |
| 4 | Peter Bais |
| 5 | Mark Butler |
| DQ | Michael Hamilton (had been first and overall) |
Medium | |
| 1 | Robert Lee Brown |
| 2 | Pren Duchane |
| 3 | Michael Carusone |
| 4 | Brian Wilson |
| 5 | Milton Mason |
| DQ | Frank Pantanoe |
Short | |
| 1 | Matthew Hepp |
| 2 | Brandon O'Connor |
| 3 | Frank Consola |
| 4 | Carmine DioGuardi |
| 5 | Lance Kellogg |
| 6 | Kevin Jackson |
| DQ | Adam Schlecter (had been 1st)) |