1959 Mr New York City - AAU
| Overall Winner George Orlando | |
Tall | |
| 1 | Kenny Hall |
| 2 | Leo Downes |
| 3 | Joe Abbenda |
| 4 | Ron Covino |
| 5 | Charles Swenson |
| 6 | Hosie Coffee |
Medium | |
| 1 | Louis Santiago |
| 2 | George Castronovo |
| 3 | Saul DeJesus |
| 4 | James Matheson |
| 5 | Stan Nudelman |
| 6 | Alton Frix |
| 7 | Neil Evans |
| 8 | Reuben Smith |
| 9 | Irwin Eisenberg |
Short | |
| 1 | George Orlando |
| 2 | Larry Gonzales |
| 3 | John Bianculli |
| 4 | Enrique Vasquez |
| 5 | Kenneth Miedrich |
| 6 | Eddie Giuliani |
| 7 | Sal Ferrari |
| 8 | Mike Torres (1) |