1958 Mr New England - AAU
| Overall Winner Ralph Becker | |
Tall | |
| 1 | Ralph Becker |
| 2 | Wally Farrell |
| 3 | Don Marion |
Medium | |
| 1 | Roger Millette |
| 2 | Henry Archambault |
| 3 | Cordell O'Connor |
Short | |
| 1 | Nathan Harris |
| 2 | Lionel Pereira |
| 3 | John Lynch (1) |
Most Muscular | |
| 1 | Wally Farrell |