1959 Mr America - AAU
| 1 | Harry Johnson [1] | |
| 2 | Ray Routledge | |
| 3 | Pete Ganios | |
| 4 | George Orlando | |
| 5 | Vern Weaver | |
| 6 | Elmo Santiago | |
| 7 | Lloyd Lerille | |
| 8 | Art Harris | |
| 9 | Kenny Hall | |
| 10 | Fred Schutz | |
| 11 | Hossein Shokouh | |
| 12 | Buddy Basil | |
| 13 | Walt Cuzzimano | |
| 14 | Tommy Johnson | |
| 15 | Leo Downs | |
| 16 | Joseph Simon | |
| 17 | Bill March | |
| 18 | Mike Ferraro | |
| 19 | Hank Wayne | |
| 20 | George Wojnowski | |
| 21 | Harry Lanehart | |
| 22 | Gene Wells | |
| 23 | Sam Martin | |
| 24 | Ed Jacobs | |
| 25 | William Crozier | |
| 26 | Pat Hensley | |
| 27 | Lowell Scott | |
| 28 | Joe Marino (1) | |
Most Muscular | ||
| 1 | Art Harris | |
| 2 | George Orlando | |