1951 Mr America - AAU
| 1 | Roy Hilligenn | |
| 2 | Malcolm Brenner | |
| 3 | Marvin Eder | |
| 3 | George Paine | |
| 5 | Pepper Gomez | |
| 6 | Keith Stephan | |
| 7 | Victor Nicoletti | |
| 9 | Joe Sanceri | |
| 9 | John Witkowski | |
| 10 | Ken Cameron | |
| - | Max Grunig | |
| - | Ed Heckinger | |
| - | Robert Elwood Holbrook | |
| - | Ed Holovchik | |
| - | Dominick Juliano | |
| - | Alvin Lee | |
| - | Newman Lewis | |
| - | Ralph Mascaro | |
| - | Allen Moraes | |
| - | Elias Rodriguez | |
| - | Stan Stanczyk | |
| - | Carlin Venus | |
| - | George Waselinko | |
| - | Monte Wolford | |
Most Muscular | ||
| 1 | Roy Hilligenn | |