1991 Extravaganza - NPC
| Overall Winner Valerie Magueri | |
HeavyWeight | |
| 1 | Leila Pavilic |
| 2 | Jodie Adams |
| 3 | Jackie Franz |
| 4 | Thea Bennington |
| 5 | Michele Zeigler |
| 6 | Thresa Bostick |
| 7 | Barbara Diaz |
MiddleWeight | |
| 1 | Dore Bowers |
| 2 | Amy Jo DiMeglio |
| 3 | Kristen Robinson |
LightWeight | |
| 1 | Valerie Magueri |
| 2 | Kelly Rosiak |
| 3 | Linda Beale |
| 4 | Vicky Noriega-Alicea |
Masters | |
| 1 | Lynn Alfone |
| 2 | Barbara Diaz |
| 3 | Terri Smith |